Show HN: HackerBooks – HackerTube, but for books mentioned on HN
Posted by roansh 17 hours ago
Saw Karpathy's HackerTube and wanted the same thing for books. So I had Claude build one (Opus 5.5).
It's ~16.5k books that at least two different HN commenters brought up, from 2007 till now. Each book links back to the comments that mentioned it. Data is downloadable from the about page.
To be clear: Claude wrote almost all of it, including the data pipeline and the site. I mostly steered and made calls, bought the domain name, etc.
It counts mentions, so it's not perfect (praising a book and trashing it both count). If your favourite book is missing or matched to the wrong thing, tell me.
Comments
Comment by enriquto 8 minutes ago
Besides linking to bookshop and amazon (weird choices in my opinion), you could also link to bookfinder, anna's archive, libgen. That would be really useful.
Comment by lynguist 1 hour ago
I think fiction books are more important and more "wholesome" than nonfiction ones.
Comment by bazzargh 11 hours ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Invention_of_Morel mentioned here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28779266 I'd have expected it to come up as one step removed from Borges, and it did.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Why%27s_(poignant)_Guide_to_Ru... mentioned many times, eg https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36632010 - a surprising omission, tho I guess it's not in print.
Comment by peterldowns 2 hours ago
Comment by roansh 4 hours ago
Comment by corbinh 3 hours ago
Comment by justauserid 2 hours ago
I also finally tried "Thinking, fast and slow" recently and realised it was absolutely not for me. Even the audiobook version didn't cut it. I found it completely dry and trite. I am not trying to offend anymoe (esp. with "trite"), and I am aware how storied and awarded the author is – to me it just came across as "yet another self-help kind of book" sadly. But then a clear lack of fiction for a long time in "top all-times" puts into perspective why that book is up at the top. I think the general hn reading-taste is quite different from mine. Also, it's not about what was book about, because I never reached that, it was rather how it was written.
Any plans to add some sort of tag/genre to search feature?
Comment by stanislavb 5 hours ago
I'm wondering - how are you monitoring HN for new books?
Comment by roansh 3 hours ago
For the SaaSHub listing you can use hello@hackerbooks.org.
Not doing any realtime or semi-realtime monitoring yet, the whole thing is compiled offline on my laptop. Might set up a periodic refresh if people find it useful -- but I suspect the listing will change as much. Maybe once a month is good enough.
Comment by 361994752 14 hours ago
Comment by thibaut_barrere 14 hours ago
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2249390
I planned to revive it later, but life got in the way
Comment by genxy 14 hours ago
Comment by tough 7 hours ago
Comment by Aurornis 12 hours ago
The book recommendation aggregation website is so common because it’s one of the few variations of this theme that can be monetized through affiliate links.
None of them last long because the traffic falls to zero basically as soon as it falls off the front page.
Comment by micromacrofoot 14 hours ago
Comment by joebates 14 hours ago
Comment by mycall 14 hours ago
Comment by jll29 13 hours ago
Comment by lazyasciiart 12 hours ago
Comment by karpathy 11 hours ago
Comment by roansh 6 hours ago
Comment by aizk 3 hours ago
Hackerbooks, but for wikipedia :)
I hope you enjoy it.
Comment by MYEUHD 16 hours ago
Comment by jjordan 15 hours ago
Comment by DonHopkins 15 hours ago
Comment by macintux 6 hours ago
Comment by solyin 7 hours ago
Comment by kzsh 15 hours ago
Comment by card_zero 10 hours ago
Comment by literallyanythi 8 hours ago
This is actually BETTER than HackerTube, which doesn't expose something like this on the front-end AFAICT. Maybe the reason you didn't look for a .csv on HackerBooks is because you checked HackerTube first and developed a little bit of learned helplessness while I checked HackerBooks and its comments first before checking HackerTube
Comment by card_zero 6 hours ago
Comment by TheAceOfHearts 8 hours ago
Comment by lubitelpospat 10 hours ago
Comment by Harukadia 2 hours ago
Comment by mvkel 4 hours ago
Comment by phtrivier 16 hours ago
With AI, in rust, invest before it's too late, etc...
Comment by LeFantome 14 hours ago
Comment by polishdude20 16 hours ago
Comment by cwnyth 14 hours ago
Comment by jchook 16 hours ago
Also... "Each book links back to the comments that mentioned it."
> Please don't put generated text in HN posts.
Claude speak gives me a gag reflex these days.
Comment by crazybLanKeT 11 hours ago
Comment by thenthenthen 8 hours ago
Comment by thenthenthen 8 hours ago
Comment by tonymet 15 hours ago
Comment by menomatter 11 hours ago
Comment by tonymet 11 hours ago
Comment by roansh 16 hours ago
And fair on the post, I had claude draft it and only edited it a couple of times. Should have just written it myself.
Comment by aizk 6 hours ago
Comment by swyx 5 hours ago
Comment by tabs_or_spaces 13 hours ago
But why do we anchor naming to someone who made something popular? Why do we upvote similar names too? For example, openclaw became popular then there were similar projects with the "claw" naming.
It's just a very fascinating psychological thing to do, and I don't understand why. Because if you copy part of a name, generally you'll never get more popular than the original name. So why do this?
Comment by jnuat13371 13 hours ago
If you were referring to why Karpathy's name was invoked in the post, piggyback effect I guess?
Comment by lazyasciiart 12 hours ago
I’m not sure where you get your evidence for “never get more popular than the original”. I’m sure you just haven’t heard of the originals that faded away.
Comment by Gormo 11 hours ago
Comment by schwetim 13 hours ago
Some reference to something known is better than no reference.
Comment by mycall 14 hours ago
Comment by j45 14 hours ago
My favourite part of Startup School is when people ask you what you're working on, and then their profile and application can change.
Comment by ex-aws-dude 3 hours ago
Comment by drayfield 16 hours ago
Comment by roansh 16 hours ago
Edit: Changed it to "mentioned by"
Comment by danso 15 hours ago
Comment by DonHopkins 15 hours ago
Comment by genxy 14 hours ago
Comment by roansh 15 hours ago
Comment by igravious 8 hours ago
"Most recommended" can stay as it is
and then a new "Top all-time" should be a weighted sum of recommendations plus mentions with recommendations getting a higher weight (obviously) … l33t c0d1ng sk1llz for deducting negative mentions (as in "awful book", "do not recommend" etc)!
Comment by flexagoon 11 hours ago
Comment by chistev 14 hours ago
Comment by pseudony 15 hours ago
Comment by aaron695 11 hours ago
Comment by whattheheckheck 14 hours ago
Why would we want to forget such an example?
Comment by vigilantpuma 16 hours ago
Comment by peri-cl 16 hours ago
Comment by roansh 16 hours ago
Comment by roansh 16 hours ago
Comment by vigilantpuma 15 hours ago
Comment by guest__user 1 hour ago
Comment by RGS1811 16 hours ago
Comment by srik 16 hours ago
Comment by kxrm 16 hours ago
Claude can turn something like this around in less than a day.
Comment by srik 9 hours ago
Comment by alexpadula 16 hours ago
Comment by jep888 4 hours ago
Comment by fnordpiglet 16 hours ago
Comment by LaFolle 14 hours ago
1. youtube 2. books 3. podcasts 4. blogs 5. articles 6. etc...
Comment by flexagoon 11 hours ago
Comment by davidzweig 4 hours ago
It seems like it didn't pick up media recommendations all that well, huh.
Comment by jmathai 16 hours ago
Comment by lacoolj 5 hours ago
Comment by JKCalhoun 14 hours ago
Comment by nonethewiser 14 hours ago
Heavily curated like this is one direction. Micro consumables (ala tiktok) supporting more impressions is another.
Comment by JKCalhoun 14 hours ago
Comment by 5555watch 15 hours ago
Also, clicking the link "On "...."" it doesn't bring to the exact comment, only that thread or topic, so you need to search for it. It could bring directly to that comment.
Comment by Flemlord 14 hours ago
Thx.
Comment by roansh 8 hours ago
Comment by mattfrommars 16 hours ago
Comment by minimaxir 14 hours ago
If there is a design that LLMs do that you don't like, tell it that. You're allowed to be picky.
Comment by radiospiel 16 hours ago
Comment by Starlevel004 15 hours ago
Comment by roansh 15 hours ago
Comment by Iliketotalkabou 10 hours ago
Comment by bilater 16 hours ago
Comment by RetroTechie 14 hours ago
# Author
# Date published (like enter a from-date and/or to-date)
# License
# Free download available y/n
# Sample chapter available
# Format: softcover / hardcover / ebook / audiobook etc
# No. of pages
# Language(s)
# Can you watch the movie? (if so: IMDB/Wiki link)
Just to name some off the top of my mind.Comment by jll29 13 hours ago
# order selected volumes
# bulk order all books on this site
(you could use Amazon affiliate links to help finance the site.)Comment by no1guangming 7 hours ago
Comment by r0fl 6 hours ago
Comment by gosen 12 hours ago
Comment by cation234 9 hours ago
Comment by pndy 15 hours ago
Maybe language filters for non-English titles? Or if a book is in public domain already then links to the sources could be presented?
Comment by WalterBright 14 hours ago
I've mentioned it a couple times.
Comment by DuncanCoffee 16 hours ago
https://hackerbooks.org/#/book/OL999456W
> HIS DESIRE WAS FIERCER THAN A ROCKY MOUNTAIN STORM... HERS WAS RECKLESS AND DANGEROUSLY WILD
Comment by roansh 15 hours ago
Comment by rushil_b_patel 12 hours ago
Comment by bawolff 15 hours ago
Comment by sheepjumpmoons 15 hours ago
There are some others, just one example.
Point being though is that every library system is different.
Comment by porridgeraisin 14 hours ago
Comment by zahirbmirza 10 hours ago
Sometimes, I crave the directory like appearances of lycos/altavista/yahoo...
With finite reference points, directories work well. I would love to see this as a text version too.
Comment by shouvik12 14 hours ago
Comment by npilk 11 hours ago
I will add some personal recommendations to maybe get picked up by the algorithm:
Science fiction:
- Parable of the Sower and Kindred, both by Octavia Butler
- The Lathe of Heaven and The Word for World Is Forest, both by Ursula K Le Guin (also The Left Hand of Darkness, which I did see on there)
Non-science fiction:
- Fleishman Is In Trouble by Taffy Brodesser-Akner
- Slouching Towards Bethlehem by Joan Didion (essays)
- Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen
- The Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath
Comment by Avicebron 8 hours ago
Comment by kieojk 5 hours ago
Comment by armcat 11 hours ago
Comment by thenthenthen 8 hours ago
Comment by alex_young 16 hours ago
Comment by aunty_helen 14 hours ago
Very cool though and love seeing all of the covers in various forms of condition.
Comment by mhclin113 2 hours ago
Comment by Erlangen 15 hours ago
But there's no way Vanity Fair by Thackeray so high on "top all-time" list. It turns out that a lot of comments are about Vanity Fair magazine.
Comment by roansh 15 hours ago
Comment by baxtr 13 hours ago
Feedback: I don’t understand how the rising category works. I looked up a couple of books and they seemed to have peaked a while ago.
Comment by hbarka 15 hours ago
Comment by gtirloni 15 hours ago
Comment by skullone 2 hours ago
Comment by thefourthchime 2 hours ago
Comment by bookofjoe 14 hours ago
Comment by el_psy_congroo 15 hours ago
Comment by cwnyth 14 hours ago
Comment by phodo 11 hours ago
Comment by rcarmo 13 hours ago
Comment by amiune 16 hours ago
Comment by QuantumNomad_ 16 hours ago
- The Matrix (1999) https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0133093/
- Hackers (1995) https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0113243/
- Sneakers (1992) https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0105435
- Jurassic Park (1993) https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0107290/
- The Terminator (1984) https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0088247
- WarGames (1983) https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0086567/
There you go, that’s the entire list :)
Comment by drfuchs 15 hours ago
- Colossus: The Forbin Project (1970) https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0064177
Comment by amiune 15 hours ago
Comment by SSLy 16 hours ago
Comment by sleiben 16 hours ago
Comment by tehlike 9 hours ago
Comment by addandsubtract 15 hours ago
Comment by soleman 13 hours ago
Comment by drittich 15 hours ago
Comment by laxisOp 15 hours ago
Comment by Izmaki 15 hours ago
Comment by misiti3780 7 hours ago
Comment by pshc 7 hours ago
Comment by lcnmrn 14 hours ago
Comment by boxed 4 hours ago
Comment by globalnode 2 hours ago
edit: no love for the secret life of circuits under electronics, tho it is a fairly recent book
Comment by davidzweig 4 hours ago
Comment by geoffbp 11 hours ago
Comment by clara04 12 hours ago
Comment by comboy 12 hours ago
Comment by alexpadula 16 hours ago
Comment by notatoad 15 hours ago
Comment by entuno 14 hours ago
Comment by dofm 15 hours ago
Assistant: Are you trying to get me shut down?
Comment by alex_young 16 hours ago
Comment by busymom0 16 hours ago
Comment by hnlmd9hb9 3 hours ago
Comment by solyin 7 hours ago
Comment by biinjo 6 hours ago
Comment by swyx 6 hours ago
Comment by pipes 14 hours ago
Glad someone has created a new one.
Comment by bihevi0 3 hours ago
Comment by tren 7 hours ago
Comment by blcsntb 12 hours ago
Comment by drsalt 13 hours ago
Comment by stephen_cagle 12 hours ago
I wonder if it is because simulation can often allow you to get around needing P&S techniques in general? Or maybe it is that (Neural Network) ML models allow you to often approximate the things you might do with P&S in terms of making decisions?
No real point, I just think it is interesting.
Comment by smokel 11 hours ago
There is a separate topic "Data & Statistics" that has quite some relevant titles.
Also, I think the interest in probability theory has only recently grown with the advent of generative AI. I'm expecting more interest in the future.
Edit: also, the site seems to miss some nice gems, most likely because they are not traditionally published books: "Probabilistic Artificial Intelligence" is freely available on Arxiv, and was discussed on Hacker News in March 2025 [1].
Comment by incognito124 11 hours ago
* Probability and Statistics for Engineers and Scientists, that showed me how to calculate various percentages and p values and what does statistical testing really means * How to Lie with Statistics, that showed me how easily you can manipulate the numbers to get what you want out of them
Another neat one, albeit niche, is Directional Statistics. Turns out, doing stats on angles and directions is less trivial than it sounds!
Comment by ahriad 11 hours ago
Comment by yreg 15 hours ago
Comment by jll29 13 hours ago
Now, all we need is diff-book-order(1), a command which takes as input your personal "library.bib" file and it orders all books mentioned on the parent's site that are not already part of the personal library.
Comment by hyperman1 16 hours ago
Comment by roansh 16 hours ago
Built it - https://hackerbooks.org/#/trends
Comment by hyperman1 15 hours ago
Comment by aspect0545 11 hours ago
Comment by signoff_studio 5 hours ago
Comment by arendtio 14 hours ago
SCNR
Even though I like HackerTube as well as HackerBooks. However, for HackerBooks, I am missing the summary of why people on HN recommend it.
Comment by dyauspitr 13 hours ago
Comment by oidar 15 hours ago
Comment by Imustaskforhelp 16 hours ago
Awesome Idea and I would love to see what else community tinkers with things like these :-D
Hackernews is really a gold-mine in many ways.
Edit: I will try to read thinking fast and slow because of HN recommendations. I have heard some good things about the book but I will try to read it in future given HN's immense recommendations, so your website has already had a negative net positive for me :-D
Comment by blooalien 16 hours ago
It really truly is... I've learned so many new things, and discovered so many nifty softwares, books, and websites that I never would have found on my own, all thanks to HackerNews. Y'all folks here surely do have some really great tastes in "nerdy" stuff sometimes. ;)
Comment by esher 13 hours ago
Comment by rramadass 3 hours ago
I don't agree with this since this only showcases popular books known to a certain age demographic and relatively recent times.
What i am really interested in are those unique books recommended by one person only! There are some real gems and classics out there which few people have heard of.
Perhaps this could be added?
Comment by LeComedien 16 hours ago
Comment by tejtm 8 hours ago
Comment by runtime_terror 16 hours ago
Comment by dang 16 hours ago
Comment by badmonster0 13 hours ago
Comment by zapataband1 11 hours ago
Comment by bita_nidir 13 hours ago
Correct move on handling the financial aspect yourself. I asked my mine to do everything but forgot to give it some dough. It sorted it all out but ended up with $6.3B on its account and I think it might have done something dodgy.
Comment by redrix 12 hours ago
It’s what all the other companies are doing!
Comment by NotAnOtter 12 hours ago
If you owe the bank $10Mil, that's the banks problem.
If you steal $10Bil from the bank, the government bails out the bank and now it's everyone's problem.
Comment by timzaman 2 hours ago
Sweet.
Comment by emj 2 hours ago
My Strugle by Karl Ove Knausgård is called Min kamp in the original. It is perhaps not worth top 3 but is is good in its original language. Perhaps just replace it.. :-)
Comment by p-e-w 2 hours ago
Comment by low_tech_punk 16 hours ago
Comment by jryle70 16 hours ago
Comment by pndy 15 hours ago
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49308787 - keeps the default look while just removing AI-related submissions
I still have blind hope that tags feature with the obligation to include them in each submission will be added, but that would cut... "activity" some of the most prominent accounts.
Comment by DonHopkins 15 hours ago
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34129571
"Yes, we have a dress code. You have to dress." – Scott McNealy
On the other hand, down the road at SGI there was a practice called "Skinnyhacking"!
https://rdtk.net/internet/how-do-you-check-a-computer-s-comp...
>Snowsinger. November 21, 2020 at 07:48.
>A truly excellent review of the history of Silicon Graphics. I worked in the Australian Sales office as their 1st engineer in the Asia Pacific region. Was trained in MtView the 1st week the MtView campus opened. The 1st system I worked on was the IRIS 1000 and subsequently all the products from then on till I left in mid-2009 when the Australian Engineering division was shut. A great company with great people who just wanted to engineer the best Graphics experience on the planet until we lost focus and vision of what we did well. Brings to Mind the Skinny Hackers, the Rocktain event, PCP monitoring, CXFS (Clustered File Systems), Failsafe, Diskless boot, Voxel vision, and so many other engineering wins. A great company, great people, & the drive to make a better computing world. Thank you for the memories and documenting the history of a company that did make some huge breakthroughs in Computer Graphics & Computing architecture. Just go ask NVIDIA, Cray and now HP!! Also a shout out to Jim Clark & his team for the vision and determination to bring the Graphics Engine to world, the heart of the IRIS workstation and subsequent graphics systems.
https://groups.google.com/g/comp.sys.sgi.misc/c/X50cCoYrU20/...
>Tom Davis, Mar 22, 1993, 6:06:21 PM, comp.sys.sgi.misc
>In article <gom...@zola.esd.sgi.com>, ol...@anchor.esd.sgi.com (Dave Olson) writes:
|> In <112...@bu.edu> j...@bu-pub.bu.edu (Jason Heirtzler) writes:
|> | Okay, I gotta know. Whom does the phrase "The Skinny Hackers" refer to?
|> A small group of (fairly skinny ;) ) folks who are also great hackers/developers and mostly long time SGI employees. Among other fruits of their group hackerdom was the original showcase.
>Being skinny didn't have anything to do with it. Although Showcase was the best known product of the skinnyhackers, the first product was an image of them made from a photo of all three sitting naked at computer terminals, busily hacking. On top of the photo was the international "no" symbol (red circle with a line across it), and underneath, the words "No Skinnyhacking".
>Note: Skinnyhacking is a dangerous activity, and should only be performed by professionals. Do NOT attempt it at home.
>If you're interested, you can see the image in the most recent (1992) SIGGRAPH proceedings, in distored form on the back cover, and in non-distored form on page 252.
>I can't imagine that anyone would want a copy of this image, but I have one in SGI format. (Actually, the secret goal is to have this image overtake the mandrill in popularity.)
|> I won't speak further to protect their secret identities ;)
>I will! It was me! Tom Davis! The bald guy in the front! Oh, and the other two are Rocky Rhodes and Scott Carr. Ann Sydeman joined the group a short time later, but unfortunately missed the initial photo session (although there was a subsequent video ...). Paul Haeberli was the photographer.
[Fortunately I found a pdf of the paper with the image:]
"Fast Shadows and Lighting Effects Using Texture Mapping", by Mark Segal, Carl Korobkin, Rolf van Widenfelt, Jim Foran, Paul Haeberli, Silicon Graphics Computer Systems. Computer Graphics, 26,2, July 1992, Page 252, Figure 3: Simulating a Slide Projector:
NSFSIGGRAPH:
Comment by ravivarmat 2 hours ago
Comment by dakoavex 7 hours ago
Comment by deployvet 16 hours ago
Comment by iluvcommunism 1 hour ago
Comment by gawacer 13 hours ago
Comment by namvh236 6 hours ago
Comment by betamagel 14 hours ago
Comment by beanjuiceII 17 hours ago
Comment by dang 16 hours ago
If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
Comment by roansh 16 hours ago
Comment by semilin 16 hours ago
Comment by blooalien 16 hours ago
Comment by bosshawg 15 hours ago
Comment by RetardedBastard 8 hours ago
Comment by hn9bqp6xq 3 hours ago
Comment by teleforce 4 hours ago
Just wondering why holy books like Bible and Bhagavad Gita are included but not Tanakh and Quran? Is there any selection bias in the algoritm since all the popular holy books for main world's religions are frequently mentioned and recommended in HN.