What to do if you discover AI models trained using your copywrighted book?

Posted by andrea81 17 hours ago

Counter12Comment7OpenOriginal

Comments

Comment by silverFork 17 hours ago

The issue is in federal courts and has not reached the supreme court. Most of the judges up to now have sided with Ai companies. They can read and digest any data apparently, the entire knowledge of humanity including whatever you post here and have ever posted your entire life. They can't download the stuff and save it though, so in effect they have to pay some licensing fee or constantly read and never store the data... don't take my word for it, check it out.

Comment by orionblastar 17 hours ago

AI content cannot be copyrighted; it goes from the case where a monkey stole a camera and took a selfie.

Comment by benoau 17 hours ago

That's not what's being decided, it's the input of copyright content and so far it is leaning strongly towards the AI companies being able to do that and only getting in trouble for pirating the material first.

Comment by verdverm 17 hours ago

The rationale is part fair use and (more) part the process is transformative.

If the Ai can output enough to violate copyright, that's when an author can make claims. Until it does, it's just speculation that it might one day do that

Comment by orionblastar 13 hours ago

You mean like using Disney characters without permission in AI art and videos?

Comment by atmosx 13 hours ago

That’s a good one, either way someone will lose (they are both “evil”) and lose big. I wouldn’t bet against AI companies though.

Comment by verdverm 5 hours ago

yeah, images are much harder for copyright I expect

the NYT case is another, but that was an older model more prone to that, and text is easier to (eg.) hash and prevent with a post-gen guardrail

Comment by 840754587 12 hours ago

[flagged]