Ask HN: Were CS profs right to look down on programming in light of modern AI?

Posted by amichail 3 days ago

Given that modern AI can automate routine programming, maybe CS professors weren't just being snobbish in the way they looked down on programming in their lectures even though most of their students were going to become programmers.

Comments

Comment by bohdanstefaniuk 3 days ago

I think in the era of AI knowing and understanding concepts of the computer science, know how to properly build an application, understand all supporting harness like logging, devops and other stuff become much more important that knowing some implementation details of each language.

Don't get me wrong, it still important, but I think understanding concepts and principles behind each application become more important

You still need to understand how database works and how to analyze performance, how to avoid N+1 problem. You still need to understand how to run your application in the cloud or some bare-bone vm. You still need to understand security concepts

Comment by manfromchina1 3 days ago

Depends on what kind of profs.Those who teach low level systems stuff absolutely need you to be able to program in C or something similar. On the theoretical side you can kinda sorta get away with very strong math skills. You open CLRS - it just gives you a pseudocode, you do efficiency/correctness analysis on it and forward you go. Then open an Automata book and realize it's all math all the way down. Not a lot of math either.

Kernel programming still resists AI so C and assembly arent going anywhere.

Comment by raccoonhands 2 days ago

wdym the way they looked down on programming? was it a thing to look down on pre-ai?